Español

Raid without a warrant and illegal detention: the case of two members of 'El4tico'‘

On the morning of February 6th, there were arbitrarily detained The young Kamil Zayas Pérez and Ernesto Ricardo Medina, members of the audiovisual initiative ‘El4tico’, from which they have disseminated critical content on the social, economic and political situation of Cuba, promoting public debate and the citizen's right to participate in the cultural and civic life of the country.

Initially, officers arrived at the home of Ernesto Ricardo Medina in the city of Holguín. According to a video circulating on social media, the officers They claimed to have a “search warrant” and demanded the immediate opening of the property. However, when Ricardo Medina specifically requested to see the warrant so he could document it, the agents insisted on entering without showing it, stating that he would have access to it “at the end.” During the same exchange, the absence of witnesses, an essential requirement for this type of proceeding, was questioned, reinforcing the presumption that the procedure was not carried out with the established formalities.

It was later learned that both Ricardo Medina and Zayas Pérez, both residents of Holguín, had been arrested and They were missing for hours until it was learned that they are being held in a unit known as ‘Everybody sings’.

For Cubalex, the detention of both is illegal under current national legislation and contrary to international human rights standards.

Analysis of home searches and arbitrary detention

This procedure is illegal under the Law No. 143 “On Criminal Procedure” Because entry and search of a private residence are subject to strict requirements. If the procedure is carried out without the occupant's consent, as occurred in this case, Article 307.2 mandates a reasoned decision from the acting authority with the approval of the public prosecutor and, furthermore, stipulates that a copy of said decision must be given to the occupant when the procedure is carried out. This omission invalidates the act from the outset, as it deprives the citizen of the right to know the legal basis, the purpose, and the scope of the search, and prevents real-time oversight of the legality of state action.

The illegality is compounded because Article 316.2 of said law requires that the search be carried out in the presence of the main resident or an adult relative and, in all cases, in the presence of two witnesses. If the search was carried out without witnesses, or without guaranteeing their effective participation, the procedure would have violated a substantial requirement that compromises the validity of all actions taken. reinforces the arbitrariness of the operation.

From a constitutional perspective, the state's actions constitute a direct violation of the inviolability of the home. The Constitution of the Republic of Cuba recognizes that no authority may enter a home without the consent of the person residing there, except as provided by law. This right is not merely an abstract principle, but a substantive guarantee that protects privacy, security, and personal freedom against abusive intrusions.

Entry by force or under the condition of an undisclosed warrant constitutes an unlawful intrusion and an abuse of power, particularly when the authorities attempt to substitute the presentation of the warrant with a demand for immediate obedience. Violation of this constitutional guarantee not only invalidates the search procedure but may also constitute a crime under Cuban criminal law, as it implies an arbitrary invasion of a home by public officials improperly exercising their duties.

In relation to the The arrest of Ernesto Ricardo Medina and Kamil Pérez Zayas is illegal. in accordance with Law 143, because deprivation of liberty is subject to a principle of strict legality. Article 341 categorically establishes that no one may be detained except in the cases and with the formalities provided for in said law.

Even if the authorities claim that the arrest occurred within the framework of a criminal investigation, Law 143 imposes essential formalities that must be fulfilled at the time of the arrest. Article 346 requires the immediate preparation of a report stating the time, date, place, and reason for the arrest, the circumstances of the arrest, and the detainee's identifying information, as well as the identification of the arresting officer and their signature alongside that of the detainee.

The illegality of the arrest also stems from its direct connection to a supposedly irregular home search. Law 143 does not authorize the automatic use of a home search as grounds for arresting individuals. A search is an investigative procedure, while an arrest is an exceptional restrictive measure; therefore, both must meet independent requirements. If the entry and search were carried out without a warrant and without witnesses, the entire process is flawed, and any arrest resulting from that procedure is illegal. This reinforces the conclusion that the deprivation of liberty does not correspond to a legitimate procedure, but to an arbitrary intervention.

Under international human rights standards, the arrest and search are also incompatible with widely recognized obligations in international law, especially those derived from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which establish that no one may be subjected to arbitrary arrest or detention, that everyone has the right to be informed of the reasons for their detention, to be brought promptly before a competent authority and to have effective remedies to challenge the legality of their deprivation of liberty.

The lack of documentary transparency, coercion to allow access to the home, the possible lack of witnesses and the detention without immediate guarantees constitute typical elements of arbitrariness according to the interpretation held by the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, which has reiterated that a detention is arbitrary not only when it lacks a legal basis, but also when it occurs in retaliation for the exercise of fundamental rights such as freedom of expression, assembly and association.

The subsequent placement of the detainees in a facility popularly known as “Everybody Sings,” associated with interrogations and criminal investigations under the control of the MININT, reinforces the presumption that the objective The main one is intimidation and submission to processes of institutional pressure.

In conclusion, both the raid and the arrest of Ernesto Ricardo Medina and Kamil Pérez Zayas are illegal under national law because they were carried out without observing the formalities required by Law 143, violating the inviolability of the home, due process, and the minimum guarantees of any detention. Furthermore, they are incompatible with international standards that prohibit arbitrary detention and protect the right to personal liberty and an effective judicial remedy. The nature of the operation, the public profile of those arrested, and the context of criminalizing dissent allow us to conclude that these events constitute an act of political harassment and a form of state reprisal intended to illegitimately restrict freedom of expression, the right to disseminate information, freedom of association, and the right to participate in public and cultural life.

CUBALEX NEEDS YOU!

In Cuba, every case we document builds a record the regime cannot ignore. Your donation sustains that work.
Thank you for trusting Cubalex and being part of this fight.