Español

The Supreme People's Court communicates "sentences", not rights.

In recent weeks, the Cuba's Supreme People's Court (TSP) published On its social media, a carousel titled “Know Cuban Law” was posted. In it, the content states that “respecting authorities and public officials” is a constitutional duty and presents it as a “pillar of social coexistence.” It then defines whom the Penal Code “protects” when they are on duty, mentioning “authorities,“ ”public officials,“ and their ”agents or assistants.“ It also lists three crimes that, according to the Supreme Court of Justice (TSP), citizens commit when they ”disrespect” these figures: contempt, resistance, and assault. Finally, it highlights the penalties associated with these crimes and adds that the sanctions can be aggravated if the act is committed by a group, if weapons or instruments of aggression are used, if serious injuries are caused, or if the acts are related to drugs, corruption, or organized crime. 

In contrast, in those publications, The TSP does not include any explanation of the legal limits that authorities must also comply with when acting. It fails to mention the duty to use force proportionally, the prohibition against abuse of power or authority, or the legal consequences when an officer oversteps their bounds. Nor does it acknowledge that the exercise of public functions is subject to controls and limits precisely to prevent arbitrary actions.

By presenting the issue only from the perspective of the behaviors that "citizens" can commit and the prison sentences (and how they are aggravated), it omits all reference to basic rights that are usually at stake in these scenarios: freedom of expression, freedom of association, the right to demonstrate and the right to personal liberty and security.

Why is this publication dangerous?

The Supreme Court is the country's highest judicial authority. When it communicates only punishment, it publicly abdicates its role of checking power. Therefore, by focusing its message on "crimes" and "punishments" and remaining silent about the limits to its authority, it is not informing the public, but rather legitimizing a penal policy that criminalizes the exercise of fundamental rights. This is not neutral communication; it is a selection of information designed to intimidate: it presents the law as a threat, not as protection.

In a context lacking independent judicial oversight, this message functions as an institutional signal. When the Supreme Court of Justice (TSP) issues it, it's not just an opinion: it's a guideline for how the law "should" be interpreted and applied. It acts as a "green light" for police, prosecutors, and judges to act more harshly, with fewer controls and without accountability.

Furthermore, the Supreme Court violates the right to information when it disseminates content of public interest on social media in an incomplete, unbalanced, and biased manner. If it chooses to discuss crimes and punishments, it must also clearly explain the minimum guarantees: the presumption of innocence, the right to remain silent, access to legal counsel, and the limits on state power, including the proportional use of force. It must also reiterate the absolute prohibition of ill-treatment and torture, enforced disappearance, and illegal and/or arbitrary detentions. It must also inform the public about the available avenues for reporting abuses and seeking redress. When it omits all of this, “Legal information” ceases to provide guidance and becomes a threat.

The effect is direct and visible: self-censorship increases. Many people remain silent for fear of ending up in prison. 

In Cuba, the triad of contempt, resistance, and attack has been used for years to punish criticism, activism, and protest. In many cases documented by Cubalex, The arrest begins arbitrarily: officers intercept the person without showing a warrant, without explaining the reason, without mentioning a prior complaint, and without informing them of their rights at that moment. The transfer and custody are usually marked by threats, shouting, humiliation, and disproportionate use of force. Charges are then brought to give legal force to what happened. If the person asks why they are being arrested or demands that their rights be respected, they are frequently charged with contempt and resisting arrest. If they try to protect themselves from blows, move away from the struggle, or loosen overly tight handcuffs, this self-protective reaction can end up being presented as an assault. This is how subsequent crimes are fabricated to justify the deprivation of liberty and cover up the abuse of power.

This is incompatible with the rule of law and with international human rights standards. Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Expression The IACHR has reiterated that the laws of disrespect They are incompatible with a democratic society because they shield officials from citizen scrutiny and generate indirect censorship. The United Nations, through the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, He has described serious patterns in cases linked to protests in Cuba: arrests without legal basis, incommunicado detention, lack of effective defense and processes without minimum guarantees.

How should the Supreme Court have done it?

If the TSP wanted to educate and fulfill its role in a state governed by the rule of law, it should have communicated with balance: not only what is punished, but also what limits the authority has and what protection the person has. It should have made it clear that criticism of officials and peaceful protest cannot be treated as crimes. And it should have offered useful guidance: what to do if detained, what to demand at the time of arrest, and what avenues exist for reporting abuses. That is informing to protect. The other is informing to intimidate and inhibit the exercise of fundamental rights.

CUBALEX NEEDS YOU!

In Cuba, every case we document builds a record the regime cannot ignore. Your donation sustains that work.
Thank you for trusting Cubalex and being part of this fight.