Español

When documenting state negligence is a crime: the use of nonexistent military figures to silence Eddy Ceballos

Eddy Ceballos
Eddy Ceballos

The arrest of Eddy Ceballos, motivated by his audiovisual recording of an abandoned military facility, raises serious legal questions. An analysis of the events under national and international law reveals systemic irregularities that violate the principle of legality, due process guarantees, and the human rights of the young content creator.

Violations of the Principle of Legality and Procedural Arbitrariness

The family has been notified of an alleged charge of “invasion of military property”, a concept that lacks a legal basis in Cuba as it is not defined in either the Penal Code (Law 151/2022) or the Military Penal Code (Law 163/2023).

This detention is inherently illegal, given that Articles 2 of the Penal Code and 3 of the Military Penal Code require that crimes be expressly defined by law before their commission, prohibiting the use of analogy. Consequently, imprisoning Ceballos on a nonexistent charge constitutes a direct violation of his right to liberty and the legal rigor that must govern the process.

The arrest of content creator Eddy Ceballos for entering and documenting an abandoned military installation has raised a number of questions among the public. Beyond the obvious arbitrariness of the action, an evaluation of the events in light of national and international law reveals a series of systemic irregularities that seriously compromise the principle of legality, due process, and fundamental human rights. 

Arbitrariness and Violations of Fundamental Rights

According to reports, the initial accusation communicated to the family bases the arrest on an alleged crime of “invasion of military property,” which lacks any legal basis, since this criminal figure does not exist in Cuban criminal legislation, neither in the ordinary Penal Code (Law 151/2022) nor in the Military Penal Code (Law 163/2023).  

The accusation of a non-existent crime tangibly demonstrates the illegality of Eddy Ceballos's detention. Both Penal Codes categorically establish, in Article 3 of the Military Penal Code and Article 2 of the ordinary Penal Code, that only those acts expressly defined as crimes prior to their commission constitute offenses, and they strictly prohibit the use of analogy to create crimes. Therefore, depriving him of his liberty under the premise of a non-existent offense constitutes a flagrant violation of the principle of legality and his right to freedom.

This initial arbitrariness is profoundly aggravated by the failure to comply with the most basic procedural guarantees. The requirement sine qua non To keep a person detained in Cuba for more than 24 hours, the corresponding formal charges must be presented, in accordance with the terms and formalities established in Article 129 of the current Criminal Procedure Law. To date, the detainee has not been clearly, promptly, and comprehensibly informed of the exact crime they are accused of, who is filing the complaint, or what evidence supports the accusation. This institutional opacity creates a situation of absolute defenselessness, as it prevents the exercise of the right to a defense and materially obstructs the appointment of a lawyer. For this appointment, it is necessary to know the formal charges in order to determine the cost of legal representation services offered by the national organization of collective law firms, the only entity legally authorized to provide this service to individuals. 

The authorities' decision to keep Eddy Ceballos in solitary confinement, which was not ordered by a competent authority and therefore lacks a reasoned and proportionate justification, violates his inalienable right as a defendant to communicate immediately and receive visits from his family and friends. This forced incommunicado detention not only violates the provisions of Article 130, Section B of the Criminal Procedure Law, but also creates an environment of defenselessness that fosters the imminent risk of subjection to physical or psychological torture—tactics used to intimidate the detainee, prevent him from exercising his constitutional rights, or coerce him into self-incrimination.

Conditions of the place and the State's obligation in this regard

Upon analyzing the factual circumstances of the scene, the criminalization of the young man's actions becomes even more untenable, as the State failed in its preventive and administrative obligations. Law 75, the “National Defense Law,” in Article 99, establishes that military zones must be properly marked and have a special surveillance and security system; therefore, the State is obligated to comply with these legal requirements in order to legally restrict access to a specific area or zone. However, the facility was in a state of complete abandonment, lacking security personnel, operational barriers, or signs indicating any type of prohibition. 

Since there was no visible warning, the citizen had no objective reason to believe he was entering a restricted area, thus eliminating any malice or criminal intent. Furthermore, the State clearly failed in its legal duty to safeguard the discontinued or decommissioned weaponry found at the site. Military authorities are obligated to guarantee the security and protection of property belonging to their units; failure to comply with this duty constitutes serious negligence in the performance of their duties, conduct that the Military Penal Code itself addresses and penalizes in Article 38. Eddy Ceballos did not commit an act of malicious intrusion, but rather documented the abandonment of the duty of care by the state administration itself.

Finally, it is essential to emphasize that Eddy Ceballos's conduct is fully protected by the legitimate exercise of the right to freedom of expression. Recording decommissioned weapons exposed to the elements in an abandoned space does not constitute a real or objective threat to national defense or security. On the contrary, the Constitution of the Republic and international treaties—specifically the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights—protect the citizen's right to seek, receive, and impart information. As elaborated in General Comment 34 of the UN Human Rights Committee, this right fully protects the use of online platforms and the documentation of reality through image and sound recordings. International law expressly prohibits states from using the concept of “national security” as an excuse to cover up their own institutional negligence, censor matters of public interest, or apply disproportionate criminal measures.

In conclusion, the detention of Eddy Ceballos constitutes an unfounded criminal prosecution and the use of analogies to fabricate crimes, in the face of an infraction by Cuban authorities. Through an opaque process that nullifies the right to defense and exposes the detainee to cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment such as isolation, an attempt is being made to criminalize and punish the legitimate exercise of freedom of expression, with the apparent purpose of diverting attention from state negligence in the protection and security of its own facilities.

CUBALEX NEEDS YOU!

In Cuba, every case we document builds a record the regime cannot ignore. Your donation sustains that work.
Thank you for trusting Cubalex and being part of this fight.