The announced measures represent the most comprehensive attempt to reconfigure the Cuban economic model since the approval of the 2019 Constitution. Beyond their economic dimension, several of them affect the constitutional property regime, the role of the socialist state enterprise, and the scope of various economic and social rights recognized by the Constitution itself.
Therefore, They cannot be presented as simple administrative decisions or ordinary public policies.
The implementation of several of the announced measures could require constitutional reforms, as they alter the property regime, the constitutional role of the socialist state enterprise, or the essential content of rights, duties, and guarantees recognized by the Constitution. In such cases, the procedure established in Article 228 would apply, according to which constitutional reforms that affect rights, duties, and guarantees must be submitted to a referendum for ratification by the citizenry.
The Cuban Constitution establishes that socialist ownership by all the people constitutes the principal form of ownership over the fundamental means of production and that the socialist state enterprise is the principal agent of the national economy. If the announced measures contemplate the privatization of state assets, the issuance of shares, the purchase and sale of public companies, the substantial expansion of private property, the subordination of state planning to market mechanisms, and the modification of the predominant role of the state enterprise, The current constitutional architecture is being altered.
Furthermore, many of these measures directly affect rights, duties, and guarantees recognized by the Constitution. These include the right to property; the right to work and labor guarantees; social security; the rights to health, education, housing, food, water, and a healthy environment; the right to equality and non-discrimination; the right to citizen participation and oversight of public assets; the right of access to public information; as well as the guarantees of effective judicial protection, due process, and redress against actions by the state or new private actors.
Consequently, any reform that modifies the content of these rights must adhere to the procedure established by the Constitution itself. Article 228 stipulates that constitutional reforms affecting rights, duties, and guarantees must be submitted to a referendum for ratification by the citizenry.
But there is an even deeper limit.
Article 229 declares the socialist system established by the Constitution irrevocable. This clause prevents any modification, even through ordinary constitutional reform, of the essential core of the political and economic model that the Constitution itself protects. If the announced measures entail a material transition to a capitalist economy through the massive transfer of state assets to private individuals, the loss of the predominant role of the socialist state enterprise, or the replacement of planning with the market as the governing mechanism of the economy, they could prove incompatible with this material and formal limitation.
In other words, the main legal barrier to implementing these measures in a stable and secure manner It does not stem solely from the international context or from US sanctions. It is found, first and foremost, within the constitutional framework itself. designed and defended by the Cuban State.
The absence of a clear constitutional basis also generates uncertainty for potential domestic and foreign investors. The stability of long-term investments requires a coherent and predictable legal framework. When far-reaching economic reforms rely solely on lower-level regulations or political decisions, while tensions persist with existing constitutional provisions, regulatory risks and the potential for future reversal increase.
Economic reforms do not mean lifting the embargo
In addition, there is a second element frequently omitted from official discourse: Economic reforms alone do not open a real path to lifting the US embargo.
The Helms-Burton Act It does not condition the normalization of bilateral relations solely on economic liberalization. Its regulatory framework links the suspension or termination of certain sanctions to verifiable progress toward the democratization of Cuba. The legislation itself distinguishes between the temporary suspension and the definitive termination of the embargo.
In general terms, the The termination of the embargo presupposes the existence of democratic institutions and the rule of law, including free elections., fair and internationally supervised processes; the effective participation of opposition political forces; respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms; judicial independence; constitutional guarantees for the exercise of political rights; as well as progress towards an economy based on the protection of property rights and mechanisms to address claims arising from confiscations carried out by the Cuban State.
As long as the existence of political prisoners, the criminalization of dissent, the one-party system, the absence of competitive elections, Political control over the judicial system and systematic restrictions on fundamental freedoms mean that no amount of economic opening will be sufficient to satisfy these conditions.
Comparative experience also demonstrates that economic reforms implemented without democratic institutions, transparency, and citizen oversight tend to favor processes of wealth concentration for the benefit of political and economic elites, rather than a true economic opening based on equal opportunities and the rule of law.
The Cuban crisis cannot be resolved solely by expanding the space for private initiative while maintaining intact the mechanisms of political control.
To build legal certainty, attract sustainable investment, and create real conditions for economic development, it is essential to simultaneously move towards legitimate constitutional reform, guarantee effective respect for human rights, release political prisoners, recognize political pluralism, ensure judicial independence, protect property through impartial institutions, and allow for free, competitive, and transparent elections.
Without these guarantees, any economic opening will remain subject to the discretion of political power., It will lack legal stability and will hardly be able to become a lasting solution to the deep crisis that Cuba is going through.
Cubalex believes that the debate on the country's economic future cannot be separated from the constitutional order, the effective protection of human rights, and the building of democratic institutions that guarantee equality before the law, transparency, and accountability. Only a transformation that integrates these elements will provide legal certainty for both citizens and investors and open a credible path toward the country's economic recovery.