On July 28, 2026, the Supreme People's Court of Cuba ratified The six-year prison sentence against the writer and independent journalist José Gabriel Barrenechea Chávez for the crime of public disorder, as well as the sentences against the other political prisoners for the same cause Rafael Javier Camacho Herrera, Yandri Torres Quintana and Rodel Bárbaro Espinosa Rodríguez.
This ratification stemmed from the analysis conducted by the highest court in the Cuban judicial system of the appeal filed by Barrenechea's defense. The court's ruling explains how criminal law is being used to punish dissent, constituting a flagrant violation of fundamental freedoms and international human rights standards.
Barrenechea and the rest of the political prisoners in this case were tried by to participate in a public and peaceful demonstration in the municipality of Encrucijada, Villa Clara province.
The defense argued before the Supreme People's Court that Barrenechea had not engaged in any acts of violence or vandalism that would justify imposing a criminal penalty. His presence was limited to the exercise of peaceful protest. It was also argued that his behavior was protected by the right to complain and freedom of expression, formally recognized in the Cuban Constitution itself.
However, the Supreme Court rejected these arguments, stating that the demonstration exceeded the bounds of constitutional protection by generating excessive noise with metal objects and obstructing pedestrian and vehicular traffic. Thus, the judges who heard the appeal classified these minor disturbances caused during a public march as a crime.
Why does this ruling violate international human rights standards?
The legal analysis of the decision issued by Cuba's highest court reveals that the State used the penal system to punish peaceful dissent, ignoring international standards on freedom of expression and public assembly. According to the General Observation No. 37 According to the UN Human Rights Committee's ruling on the right to peaceful assembly, recognized in Article 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, temporary traffic disruptions, noise, or chanting do not negate the peaceful nature of a protest. Disruptions to daily life are inherent in any public demonstration in a democratic society and must be tolerated by the authorities.
The Cuban regime improperly equates traffic inconveniences or the noise of pots and pans with violence or public disorder, penalizing behaviors that are internationally protected.
Likewise, the defined standards The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) and other international bodies demand that restrictions on fundamental rights comply with the principles of necessity and proportionality. Imprisonment is an extremely serious penalty that should not be used to punish non-violent protesters.
The imposition of a 6-year prison sentence for participating in a pot-banging protest aims intimidate o inhibit the exercise of peaceful protest in Cuba, sending the message that any demand for rights will be severely punished.
Finally, the principles of presumption of innocence and of typicality They demand that criminal penalties be based on individual actions committed by the accused. In this case, the Supreme Court upheld the conviction, stating that Barrenechea was part of the group's dynamics, holding him collectively responsible for the alleged crowd disturbances without demonstrating any violent acts directly attributable to him.
Conclusions
The ratification of these sentences demonstrates the continued manipulation of the Cuban Penal Code and the justice system to persecute critical voices, independent journalists, and citizens who demand dignified living conditions. Cubalex reiterates that peaceful protest is not a crime. Therefore, we reiterate our demand for the immediate and unconditional release of José Gabriel Barrenechea Chávez and all those imprisoned in Cuba for exercising their rights.